About two weeks ago I posted some quotations of John Henry Newman on the River Thames Beach Party. One of his lines which has stuck out since comes from Volume I, Sermon 12 of his Parochial and Plain Sermons:
…conforming their families to the spirit of the Prayer Book…
This, I know, is mostly void of context, but does provide an entry point for today’s post. In what way is the Prayer Book authoritative in one’s domestic prayer life? In Thomas Cranmer’s preface to the 1549 Prayer Book, some important points are made about the place of the BCP in the life of faithful. In it Cranmer writes, “by this order the curates shall need none other books for their public service, but this book and the Bible.” By this it is plain that public services in England are to be according to the standard of the Prayer Book. But what about private spirituality of individuals/families? To that end we have the following found near the end of the preface:
Though it be appointed in the afore written preface, that all things shall be read and sung in the church in the English tongue, to the end that the congregation may be thereby edified: yet it is not meant, but when men say Matins and Evensong privately, they may say the same in any language that they themselves do understand. Neither that any man shall be bound to the saying of them, but such as from time to time, in Cathedral and Collegiate Churches, parish Churches, and Chapels to the same annexed, shall serve the congregation.
Cranmer did not have the expectation that the morning and evening offices would be recited by each and every person of the church each day. On the contrary, the 1549 makes the assumption that the offices were to be done in public officiated by clergy as the opening rubric begins, “The Priest beeyng in the quier…” This rubric was changed in the subsequent editions of the Prayer Book, though the assumption of it being a public liturgy remains constant: “Churches without such an offering of Morning and Evening Prayer are clearly alien to the system and principles of the Book of Common Prayer” (St. Dunstan’s Plainsong Psalter, p. 227). It is worth pointing out, at this point, that in most provinces of the Anglican Communion, clergy are required to pray the office according to their respective province’s authorized texts. This requirement and the expectation that each parish would offer the office are not unrelated. The absence of Morning and Evening Prayer at the majority of parish churches is not only a sad state of affairs, but an aberration from the Anglican tradition and the expectations of the Book of Common Prayer that cannot be overstated.
The American Church, from the 1789 BCP on through the 1979 edition, has included further evidence of there being a difference in public and private conformity to the Prayer Book. What I am referring to here is the inclusion of “Prayer to be used in families.”* The 1789/1892 version (they are identical) provided short prayers for the beginning and ending of each day to be said kneeling after the head of household has convened everyone. The 1928 BCP expanded this section to include an additional “shorter form” as well as “additional prayers” which cover a variety of occasions. The 1979 re-structured the family prayers along with the Daily Office to be four-fold and provides prayers for morning, noon, evening, and the close of day. The “additional prayers” of the 1928 have been relocated to a different part of the ‘79 (to a new, larger, section called “Prayers and Thanksgivings”). The rubrics of the ’79’s are likewise expanded:
For convenience, appropriate Psalms, Readings, and Collects are
provided in each service. When desired, however, the Collect of the
Day, or any of the Collects appointed in the Daily Offices, may be used
instead.
The Psalms and Readings may be replaced by those appointed in
a) the Lectionary for Sundays, Holy Days, the Common of Saints, and
Various Occasions, page 888.
b) the Daily Office Lectionary, page 934
c) some other manual of devotion which provides daily selections for the
Church Year.
These make it clear that the family prayers may be made to look quite similar to the Daily Office proper if one desires, but not necessarily so. As rubric ‘C’ make clear, other devotional sources which provide daily selections are appropriate.
So, what does this mean for the lay person desiring to conform their prayer life to that of the Book of Common Prayer? First, if circumstances allow, they should attend the office offered at their parish church. If, like the majority of us, they live in a place where the office is not offered, they may desire to pray the office at home. If one would rather not pray a public liturgy privately, the BCP proffers devotions to be used at home that are quite flexible. This flexibility includes other unspecified schema of readings and psalms as well as leaving a great deal of latitude for the selection of prayers. To refer again to St. Dunstan’s Plainsong Psalter:
The [Prayer Books of Edward VI] and Queen Elizabeth’s Primers showed that they by no means intended to hinder, but rather to encourage those who still wished to observe the ancient hours of Prayer: and the Devotions of Bishop Cosin, with other Manuals framed on the same model, have given many devout souls the opportunity of supplementing the public Mattins and Evensong with prayers at the other hours that equally breathed the spirit of the ancient Church.
P. 227
In this view, the offices of the Prayer Book are meant to be practical (it is common knowledge that public recitation of all the hours of the office at time of the Reformation were aggregated into two or three blocks rather than seven) and to encourage the prayer lives of the people. The Prayer Book minimum (as repugnant a phrase as that is) seems to be that one take time at the beginning and the end of the day to read some Scripture, pray for ourselves, and pray for others. Whether this marking of morning and evening is as simple as the form Martin Luther provides in the Small Catechism** or as complex as The Anglican Breviary is going to be largely determined by one’s own gifts from the Spirit and the circumstances of one’s daily life.
——-
*The custom of including private devotions for families occasionally bound with the BCP goes back to the reign of Elizabeth I. The American BCP takes, for its model, the devotions published by Edmund Gibson in 1705. As stated above, the ‘79 restructured the family prayers to be more flexible and mirror, if desired, the Daily Office.
**Because of the brevity of Luther’s form and my fond memory of it from my youth, I have included it in its entirety below:
MORNING AND EVENING PRAYERS
In the morning
. . . when you rise, make the sign of the cross and say, “In the name of God: the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit. Amen.”
Then, kneeling or standing, say the Apostles’ Creed and the Lord’s Prayer. Then you may say this prayer:
“I give you thanks, heavenly Father, through your dear Son Jesus Christ, that you have protected me through the night from all harm and danger. I beseech you to keep me this day, too, from all sin and evil, that in all my thoughts, words and deeds I may please you. Into your hands I commend my body and soul and all that is mine. Let your holy angel have charge of me, that the wicked one may have no power over me. Amen.”
After singing a hymn (possibly a hymn on the Ten Commandments) or whatever your devotion may suggest, you should go to your work joyfully.
In the evening
. . . when you retire, make the sign of the cross and say, “In the name of God: the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit. Amen.”
Then, kneeling or standing, say the Apostles’ Creed and the Lord’s Prayer. Then you may say this prayer:
“I give you thanks, heavenly Father, through your dear Son Jesus Christ, that you have graciously protected me through this day. I beseech you to forgive all my sin and wrong which I have done. Graciously protect me during the coming night. Into your hands I commend my body and soul and all that is mine. Let your holy angels have charge of me, that the wicked one may have no power over me. Amen.”
Then quickly lie down and sleep in peace